Lords of Serendipity – Another Meh Campus Novel

Posted

I love a good campus novel. I’ve previously written about my four favorites, about another very solid (if rather different in tone) entry, and about one ‘also-ran.’

Thus, I was quite excited to dive into a new entrant, Randy Boyagoda’s Lords of Serendipity, published in September. Billed as “A Moving Campus Satire of Strivers, Gatekeepers, and University Dreams,” it sounded terrific.

Unfortunately, it isn’t moving. At least not for me. It’s primarily annoying. Ultimately, it’s another ‘meh.’

This isn’t to say it doesn’t contain a few gems. Indeed, despite some grammatical tics that are grating—such as a lack of quotation marks indicating speech—the novel begins with promise, including this nugget regarding main character and professor of statistics Jack Bayern:

“Jack was far from an active researcher, but at least he wasn’t interested in pedagogy. People who worked on pedagogy were the gym teachers of the university. As in, no real athlete would be a gym teacher. No real professor would care about their teaching.”

Delicious. (I sometimes write in pedagogy.)

And this, prefacing Jack’s wonderful first lecture (Allard Hamburger is Jack’s TA):

“While Jack was writing his lecture and Allard was arranging his latest set of guaranteed B’s, [students] had been in five days of orientation to university—a kind of extended kindergarten gym class, corporate wellness retreat, and sexual violence seminar, interleaved with nightly orgiastic hives, noodle slurping, die-ins for Palestine or smaller counterprotests for Israel, texted breakups with high school beloveds, and weepy video chats with family. At this, the start of their first class in university, the students were very quiet.”

So, the setup is solid. Unfortunately, the follow-through—which is naturally most of the novel—falls flat. While it is fun to pick on the greed and incompetence of the modern university, for a campus novel to work, there needs to be something redeeming in it all, or at least a flash of something redeeming. The concept is that although we are in a bad place—and indeed we really are—a university’s constituent parts, which are, most fundamentally, people, remain worth rooting for. They could just turn it all around, even if you know they won’t quite manage. An intrinsically interesting story would also help. But in Boyagoda’s hands, it’s pretty much a tedious horror show all the way down. He sketches characters that certainly could have been made charming or redeemable, but he seems determined not to let that happen. Every time a character nods toward developing into something one might root for, Boyagoda slams them back into ‘sigh’ territory.

And I’m unsure why. Whether it’s on account of genuine bitterness about university—what’s going on at the University of Toronto, anyway?—or, as seems much more likely, an unrelated authorial purpose for the novel, it transformed potential into aggravation after aggravation, the novel ending in… you got it, the final aggravation.

For many an academic, the campus is a microcosm of our world. Despite great potential, humans always—inevitably—screw it up. Yet, even so, the potential shines through. There is ever a chance those university humans will stop being so transactional and appreciate what they could collectively accomplish. Lords of Serendipity doesn’t read that way. At one point, with Professor Bayern visiting in Italy, we get this:

“Methodically visiting famous fountains around Rome, he sat on veined stone ledges and read biographies of mathematicians associated with the Manhattan Project and then a novel about Wittgenstein, G. E. Moore, and Bertrand Russell, all of which summoned visions of universities full of great minds who accomplished good and sometimes even great things. Also bad things, terrible things. But they were never just mediocre and cowardly, like the people in Jack’s university world.”

Nice. But then… do you really want to read a novel about just the mediocre and cowardly? I have enough aggravation in my real life. Believe me, I do. So, I’d like my campus novel to have at least a breath of hope for something besides, and I didn’t find it here.


Subscribe

If you’d like to receive an email when new posts appear, subscribe here.


Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *